18 Adorable Baby’s First Christmas Keepsake Ornaments

Emily Wendzich
Written by
Last update:

A toddler’s first Christmas is a magical time. It is attended by excited grandparents that would love to add more to the holiday season with beautiful keepsakes that they can treasure for years to come.

As Christmas approaches, the most common challenge that parents face is finding the best Christmas ornaments for their toddlers. There are plenty of options, but not all of them are actually worth the investment. Here are some of my absolute favorites.

NameCategoryProduct
LifeSong Milestones Personalized Baby's First Christmas Round Barky Ornament New Parent Gift IdeasBest OverallLifeSong Milestones Personalized Baby's First Christmas Round Barky Ornament New Parent Gift Ideas
Scrabble TilesBudget PickScrabble Tiles
Baby’s First Christmas OrnamentUpgrade PickBaby’s First Christmas Ornament

1. LifeSong Milestones Personalized Baby's First Christmas Round Barky Ornament New Parent Gift Ideas

Our rating: 9 / 10

LifeSong Milestones Personalized Baby's First Christmas Round Barky Ornament New Parent Gift Ideas

Check Price on Amazon

LifeSong Milestones Personalized Baby's First Christmas Round Barky Ornament is an excellent Baby's First Christmas ornament. If you love this product, check out this listing of 18 surprising Christmas ornaments. Each product is amazing and comes in a variety of styles. Choose the style and the look that best suits you and your family and get a lifetime of use from each product.

There is a personalization option available on all products, which is great because it allows each family to get a unique design that expresses their personalities. This particular ornament allows you to include a name on the ornament, which allows each family to have a personal keepsake they can use year after year.

The quality of the material used to make the ornament is excellent. The ornament is made from wood and is handmade. It comes with a satin ribbon for hanging. The design even matches the look of a traditional Christmas tree ornament from years ago, which is great for creating a treasured keepsake that will last for years to come.

2. Willow Tree Sign

Our rating: 9 / 10

Willow Tree Sign

Check Price on Amazon

If you need to fill up your Christmas tree, this Willow Tree Sign for Love Ornament will do the trick. This beautiful keepsake figure of an angel is made from polystone and hand-painted. It’s a great gift to show that special someone how much you love them.

The angel can stand on its own power, and it really looks lifelike. It would make a great asset to anyone’s holiday decoration.

3. Personalized First Christmas 2020 Ornament

Our rating: 9 / 10

Personalized First Christmas 2020 Ornament

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Available in two different sizes
  • Hand painted
  • Personalizable
  • Quick turnaround time
  • Beautiful quality ornament
  • Cute Love Heart
  • High quality craft
  • Stylish
  • Lovely design
  • Easy to order

The Personalized First Christmas Ornament are handmade crafts that will last a lifetime. Our one-of-a-kind personalized first Christmas ornament will be treasured for years to come!

The ornament features the standard Snowman with Baby Jesus in his arms, as well as Personalizations including the child’s name. It’s a great way to tell your child that they are special on their first holiday season.

The personalized first Christmas ornament back is hand painted.

4. Personalized Baby's First Christmas Girl Pink Ornament 2020

Our rating: 9 / 10

Personalized Baby's First Christmas Girl Pink Ornament 2020

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Hand-painted
  • Very detailed
  • Can be personalized
  • Has a hanger
  • Made from copyrighted materials
  • Can stand up on its own
  • Made from durable materials
  • Resin

Cons:

  • High price
  • Not BPA-free
  • May not look exactly like the picture

We like that this simple baby's first Christmas girl ornament has a hanger so it'll be ready to hang in your Christmas tree. The detailing and lifelike features are fantastic.

This particular ornament comes with a silky pink bow that can be removed if it's not to your preference. It is hand painted with a variety of acrylic paints which makes it quite unique. If you intend to order this ornament, allow a month for shipping.

Bottom line: This is a cute baby's first Christmas ornament that can be tailor-made to your preferences as far as the year it was born, the name and the color of the bow and even the hair and eye colors. The hand painting makes for a very unique ornament that will look great in your Christmas tree.

5. Hallmark Keepsake Ornament 2019 Year Dated Baby Boy’s First Christmas Blue Teddy Bear Booties

Our rating: 9 / 10

Hallmark Keepsake Ornament 2019 Year Dated Baby Boy’s First Christmas Blue Teddy Bear Booties

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Bright and colorful
  • Fine detailing
  • Adorable as a memento
  • Can hang on a Christmas tree or anywhere in your home
  • Lights up when you press the belly
  • Fun to look at
  • Even more fun to touch
  • Great for a baby shower gift
  • High quality and reasonable price
  • Lightweight and made of sturdy resin

Cons:

  • Requires two AA batteries (not included)
  • A lot of little pieces to keep track of ¦ luckily, the packaging is very good.
  • The belly button and the green teddy bear button are in different colours
  • The quality is not as good as a larger, more expensive brand
  • The weight is on the light side

One reviewer wrote, ¦…I bought this as a shower gift. When I helped put it together, I thought, now why didn’t I buy this for myself.” It will be a beautiful addition to any nursery, or to any bedside table.

6. Our First Christmas as a Family of Three 2020 Christmas Tree Ornament

Our rating: 9 / 10

Our First Christmas as a Family of Three 2020 Christmas Tree Ornament

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Available in three different color options
  • Composed of quality materials
  • Now you can preserve precious memories
  • Completely customizable

Unique Baby Shower Gifts.

If you want to create a meaningful Christmas tree ornament, then this one is perfect for you. It can be customized to suit your family and it can be created using your own choice of photos.

This Christmas Tree Ornament is made from quality materials. You have the option of choosing from three colors, and you can hang it on your Christmas tree or centerpiece.

7. Hallmark Mahogany Ornament

Our rating: 9 / 10

Hallmark Mahogany Ornament

Check Price on Amazon

With raised beaded detailing on both sides of the ornament, this hand-painted, 12-inch-tall ornament will charm anyone who sees it. It’s also the perfect companion for a gingerbread house.

It features a delicately crafted 3D wood-and-foam carriage, which glows in the dark. Three wise men, dressed in their finest, complete the scene with holly and evergreen accents.

It’s a small world, after all! That’s an appropriate thought to share with your friends when you give this holiday ornament. It’s a reminder that the Christmas spirit is alive and well … and that it’s contagious.

8. Mama Papa Baby Bear Christmas Ornament 2020

Our rating: 8 / 10

Mama Papa Baby Bear Christmas Ornament 2020

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Beautiful and delicate design
  • The piece itself is very lightweight
  • Great gift to tuck in your baby’s stocking or a little one’s hand to remember their first Christmas
  • Great price and quality
  • Perfect decoration for your wreath

For the cheapest and most affordable Christmas ornaments for babies, check out our number one pick, Mama Papa Baby Bear Christmas Ornament 2020 – Our First Christmas as a Family Rustic Wooden Wood Engraved Ornament. It comes in three different sizes, so you have a choice based on how you would like to frame it.

Large size measures about 5×3 inches and just fits in the palm of your hand. This ornament is made with a laser-cut frame to include any name you want. Then, it’s handcrafted, stained, wiped and finally sealed with a durable and high-quality varnish.

The laser-cut ornament includes an adorable teddy bear and baby with a ribbon that says which family relations are depicted. This ornament will become a beautiful family heirloom.

9. Baby Ornament Keepsake Kit

Our rating: 8 / 10

Baby Ornament Keepsake Kit

Check Price on Amazon

(Blue)

This keepsake baby ornament kit comes with everything you need to safely create an adorable keepsake for your new baby. After mixing the color, press the appropriate hand or foot into the mold. You can continue to pour more color on top of the imprints if you like. Allow the hand or foot imprints to dry and then place the ornament on the stand. You can use the foam-bottomed foot to give you extra support while pouring the color onto the ornament. This kit comes with four colors of paint as well as an earthenware ornament base, metal stand, four ribbons of different sizes, a sheet of letters or numbers for personalization and a paintbrush. The colors are blue, pink, yellow and green.

This baby ornament kit is designed for new baby additions and features a blue, pink or yellow footprint and hand print paired with a hand-painted first holiday ornament to keep for a lifetime. The kit includes one metal peg ornament stand, four ribbons of different sizes, a sheet of letters or numbers for personalization and a paintbrush. Crafted of safe polyresin material, this keepsake ornament is safe for those over 3 years.

10. Personalized Angel Ornament Engraved Clear Iridescent Stained Glass Window Sun Catcher Baby’s First Christmas Tree Decoration Holiday Decor Memorial Remembrance Sympathy Gift J Devlin ORN 215-1 EO104

Our rating: 8 / 10

Personalized Angel Ornament Engraved Clear Iridescent Stained Glass Window Sun Catcher Baby’s First Christmas Tree Decoration Holiday Decor Memorial Remembrance Sympathy Gift J Devlin ORN 215-1 EO104

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Six different color choices
  • Comes with its own handle and suction cup
  • Can be personalized with the name of your choice
  • Has a cord for hanging
  • Beautiful design

The Personalized Angel Ornament from J Devlin is the best choice for a memorial ornament. It’s also a great choice for someone looking for a something out of the ordinary for a baby’s first Christmas ornament.

This ornament is beautifully handcrafted with iridescent stained glass, and it’s designed to look like the winged figures of angels. It’s sturdy enough to be hung either inside or outside, and it’s complete with its own suction cup for hanging.

The Personalized Angel Ornament is also quite large, measuring about 5 inches tall, and it can be engraved with the name of the recipient. It’s not cheap but the quality is there, and it’s an appropriate ornament for someone special.

11. Andaz Press Personalized Laser Engraved Wood Christmas Ornament

Our rating: 8 / 10

Andaz Press Personalized Laser Engraved Wood Christmas Ornament

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • * Unique and modern design * Materials are safe and durable * Safe for baby to play with * Package comes with a beautiful gift bag * Engraved name can be customized * Comes with a 1 year manufacturer’s warranty * Made from high quality wood

Personalized Gifts, Personalized Baby Gift, 1st Christmas Gift.

If you’re looking for beautiful and unique first Christmas ornaments for your baby, we’re sure that the Andaz Press personalized baby ornament will fit the bill. The box includes one high-quality wooden ornament, a beautiful gift bag, and a free gift card.

The wood used to make the ornament is carefully chosen, kiln dried, and finished with environmentally friendly stains to create a durable and sturdy design. This ornament is designed with a non-toxic finish, and it can be a great choice for your baby’s nursery.

12. Baby’s First Christmas Ornament

Our rating: 8 / 10

Baby’s First Christmas Ornament

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Very cute
  • Much larger than expected
  • Blocks can be put together to form interesting shapes and figures

The Baby’s First Christmas Ornament (2020) Large is an adorable baby shower ornament that is stylish and fun to look at.

The ornament features baby blocks arranged as new born, six month, and one year old blocks. This could make it a great baby shower gift for expectant mothers.

Each set of blocks is laser etched with your child’s name, birth date, weight and height. The ornament comes in three sizes depending on the age of your baby.

13. Hallmark Keepsake Christmas Ornament 2018 Year Dated Baby's First Rattle Year Dated Porcelain

Our rating: 8 / 10

Hallmark Keepsake Christmas Ornament 2018 Year Dated Baby's First Rattle Year Dated Porcelain

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • It is especially made to preserve your baby's handprint and footprint
  • It has a built-in picture hanger for easy display
  • It consists of Porcelain
  • The year 2018 is shown in the bottom of the image
  • It is a beautiful keepsake to have for that special infant

Cons:

  • The personalization font is quite small
  • There is no guarantee for replacement if damaged

With a lot of great features and high-end materials, this Christmas ornament will be a treasured keepsake from a little one's first Christmas.

14. Scrabble Tiles

Our rating: 8 / 10

Scrabble Tiles

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Scrabble Tiles make a one-of-a-kind keepsake that people will love
  • Each tile is made from a high-quality material for maximum durability
  • This is a set of 100 tiles that you can use to spell out. .. whatever you want!
  • Your child will love to create words with these tiles

Cons:

  • Your child might be a little too young to appreciate this gift right away
  • Younger children may not be able to spell out words properly

Is your kid obsessed with Scrabble? These magnetic tiles include 100 tiles featuring letters and numbers that you can spell out whatever you want. Parents LOVE that this gift will spark the creativity in their infant or toddler without the worry of them getting bored.

15. Mud Pie Merry & Bright First Christmas Baby Rocking Horse Ornament

Our rating: 7 / 10

Mud Pie Merry & Bright First Christmas Baby Rocking Horse Ornament

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Easy to fill out
  • Economical

We found the Mud Pie Merry & Bright First Christmas Baby Rocking Horse Ornament a very affordable and aesthetically pleasing option for baby’s first Christmas ornament. It is made of durable quality felt and is then accented with a festive ribbon. It also has a nice place on the back to fill out with baby’s name and the year of the tree ornament.

The only problem that we found is that the rubber band that attaches the horse’s head sometimes popped off. This is something that could be easily fixed with a bit of glue or tape, so it should not be a problem for long.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

How do you make a baby's first Christmas ornament?

You can use a tradition that’s been around for decades to make a festive baby’s first Christmas ornament. Here’s what you need:

  • 1 Ballpoint Pen
  • 2 Washable Pens
  • 1 Bowl
  • Washi Tape (optional)
  • 1 Pair of Scissors
  • Baby’s First Christmas Ornament Template

Something to hang the ornament. Using a vintage ornament hanger works great for this.

{1}. Wash your hands to make sure they’re clean.
{2}. Take your pens and cut off the top part of the pen.
{3}. Make sure the top of the pen fits inside the top part of the ornament where the round top of the ballpoint pen would normally be.
{4}. Using the washable pens, write the month you were born on the pen.

What do you buy for baby's first Christmas?

A personal ornament or a keepsake ornament is a wonderful gift that will last for the rest of your child’s life or even beyond. It’s a gift that will give the family a lot of pleasure.

If you’re going to buy a gift that lasts a lifetime, try to get your child a personalized ornament or one that has a lot of sentimental value. Make it something that is going to spark family conversations during the Christmas season.

What is the most expensive Hallmark Keepsake Ornament?

How do you make baby glitter footprint ornaments?

Immerse baby’s foot in a tray of glitter flakes or in a jar of acrylic paints. The best way to make an impression is to let the baby walk towards a flat surface like a large piece of paper on the floor. Remember to close off the area with a large garbage bag or plastic sheeting, or wear old clothes or a painter’s mask and roll up your sleeves, because you’re going to get glitter all over you. Then flatten baby’s foot on the paper and cover with another piece of paper. Use two pieces of paper to make a darker imprint. Wait until the mixture is dry. Spray the painted footprint with a layer of acrylic spray to make the colors of the glitter stand out. Glue the print to a flat surface like a cardboard cutout, item from which you can hang for display.

Conclusion

To ensure we’re picking the best Christmas ornaments for babies, we’ve looked at over a dozen recommendations from other websites, buyer’s guides, and reviews so that we can provide you with our top recommendations based on safety, usefulness, and style.

Little people will love these vintage Christmas tree ornaments, Santa’s new sleigh, Christmas stocking, and letterpress angel, while other adorable options include a snowman who never melts, and a little angel who is always watching over Christmas.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
LifeSong Milestones Personalized Baby's First Christmas Round Barky Ornament New Parent Gift IdeasBest OverallLifeSong Milestones Personalized Baby's First Christmas Round Barky Ornament New Parent Gift Ideas
Scrabble TilesBudget PickScrabble Tiles
Baby’s First Christmas OrnamentUpgrade PickBaby’s First Christmas Ornament